There's a booklet option that auto-margins overflow on additional pages. It's even binder ready. It's going to use whatever paper size is in the Properties dialog which I believe is A4 be default..
The harder way is printing overflow in separate print queues and setting identical Top-Margin under Properties>Page Setup>Specify Margin after selecting Normal and Top-Staple; with Fit to Page on the main dialog.
The problem you can't get around without some slicer program: You can only specify margin for one or all sides under Adobe and OS dialogs. The staple fields are the only reason you get to set just one.